MELC 9 Q4

MELC 9 Q4

Welcome back to our new lesson today !

MELC 9:

Judge the relevance and worth of ideas, soundness of author’s reasoning

and the effectiveness of the presentation.

Enabling Competencies

Judge the validity of the text listened to.

At the end of the lesson, learners are expected to:

⮚     Analyze the information contained in the listened to.

⮚     Interpret the message conveyed in the material viewed

⮚     Judge the relevance and worth of ideas, soundness of author’s reasoning and the effectiveness of the presentation.

Are you ready to learn new skills?

Yes or Offcourse? :)

Poll

Before we start, let me ask you, how are you today?

• Excited

• Happy

• Contented

• Ok

Introduction

We have five macro skills namely speaking, listening, viewing, reading, and writing. Listening is very important in everyday living since listening allows us to give feedback and response. Effective listening requires an ability to evaluate whether we should believe the point being raised or not. It involves assessing the weight of the evidence used to support it.

Read the statements and answer the questions that follow.

 

A. It is going to rain because it is cloudy. The wind is picking up and the air smells damp.                   

B. All Filipinos are generous and kind like Senator Manny Pacquiao

Guide Questions:

1. Which of the two statements do you agree with? Explain your answer.

2. What made you agree with the statement you have chosen?

 

EVIDENCE

is the available body of facts or information indicating whether a belief or proposition is true or valid.

What are the steps in validating and evaluating evidence?

Take a look at your LeaP copy

FOUR TYPES OF EVIDENCE

1. STATISTICAL EVIDENCE - It is known as the strongest type of evidence. It comes in a form of number, percentage, or surveyed type data.

 

Example: 75% of women in Tayabas City…

8 out of 10 pediatricians recommend…

16 members of the legislative agreed upon…

 

2. TESTIMONIAL EVIDENCE - Use of celebrities is the core of this second type of evidence. However, experts and authorities can also be used to collect testimonial evidence.

 

Example: Heart Evangelista, a well-known actress and fashion buff, recommends that Olay lotion is good on our skin.

3. ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE - It is often dismissed as untrustworthy and meaningless. When the speaker does storytelling, anecdotal evidence is utilized.

 

Example: After living for decades in Quezon, I can honestly say that the people there are kind and hospitable.

 

4. ANALOGICAL EVIDENCE - It is regarded as the weakest evidence. When information about something is scarce and little is known, analogical evidence is often used in a formal argument to increase credibility of the proof.

 

Example: If we are going to ban firearms, we should also ban cars because they cause many more deaths than firearms do.

Open Ended

So, what are the types of evidence ?

Can you type it? :)

DEVELOPMENT

Ministerial. Then, answer the questions below.

 

“In fact, our support should be strongest where rights are threatened the most. We seem incapable of upholding minimum standards for humanity in many parts of the world. That this comes at a time when humankind is richer and more technologically advanced than ever before is all more painful. Eighteen years ago, when I first began working at the United Nation Refugee Agency, there were just 20 million displaced people worldwide and the numbers were falling. Today, there are over 65 million displaced people, and the numbers are rising. More countries are experiencing some form of violent conflicts today than any time thirty years ago. UN peacekeepers now comprise the second largest group of forces deployed overseas and are often required to serve when there is little or no peace to be kept. Against this backdrop, it is easy to dismiss our institutions as flawed or ineffective.”

Questions to Answer:

1. What is the point/claim raised in the excerpt?

2. What types of evidence are used?

3. Are the pieces of evidence enough to support the point/claim? Why? Why not?

Open Ended

1. What is the point/claim raised in the excerpt?

Open Ended

2. What types of evidence are used?

Open Ended

3. Are the pieces of evidence enough to support the point/claim? Why? Why not?

Engagement

Analyze the transcribed speech of Jack Symonds entitled “Social Media Corrupts Human Interaction”. You may also watch the video at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hCq0V_edbY. Then, accomplish the diagram.

Analyze the transcribed speech of Jack Symonds entitled “Social Media Corrupts Human Interaction”. You may also watch the video at

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hCq0V_edbY. Then, accomplish the diagram.

Poll

What is argumentation again?

• point or claim

• an evidence

• identifying the point or claim that the author is trying to prove

• a form of logic

Assimilation

 

Multiple Choice

Directions: Choose the letter that corresponds to the type of evidence given.

A. Analogical Evidence B. Testimonial Evidence

C. Anecdotal Evidence D. Statistical Evidence

1. Studies show that handwashing practices could cut the rate of respiratory infections by more than 20%.

• a

• b

• c

• d

Multiple Choice

Directions: Choose the letter that corresponds to the type of evidence given.

A. Analogical Evidence B. Testimonial Evidence

C. Anecdotal Evidence D. Statistical Evidence

______2. According to WHO, about 16 million girls between ages 15-19 and around 1 million girls under 15 give birth each year.

• a

• b

• c

• d

Multiple Choice

Directions: Choose the letter that corresponds to the type of evidence given.

A. Analogical Evidence B. Testimonial Evidence

C. Anecdotal Evidence D. Statistical Evidence

3. Studies show that the use of technology increases self-efficacy.

• a

• b

• c

• d

Multiple Choice

4. The Philippine poverty rate decreased from 23.3% in 2015 to 16.7% in 2018 and is expected to decline further in the following years.

Directions: Choose the letter that corresponds to the type of evidence given.

A. Analogical Evidence B. Testimonial Evidence

C. Anecdotal Evidence D. Statistical Evidence

• a

• b

• c

• d

Multiple Choice

5. I have seen my classmate struggle from discrimination. It breaks my heart to see people mistreat them because they look different. We must stop discrimination and start looking at each other equally.

Directions: Choose the letter that corresponds to the type of evidence given.

A. Analogical Evidence B. Testimonial Evidence

C. Anecdotal Evidence D. Statistical Evidence

• a

• b

• c

• d

Poll

Reflection

Personal Assessment on Learner’s Level of Performance

Using the symbols below, choose one which best describes your experience in working on each given task. Be guided by the descriptions below:

★ - I was able to do/perform the task without any difficulty. The task helped me in understanding the target content/ lesson.

✔ - I was able to do/perform the task. It was quite challenging, but it still helped me in understanding the target content/lesson.

?- I was not able to do/perform the task. It was extremely difficult. I need additional enrichment activities to be able to do/perform this task.

• star

• check

• Question Mark

• Heart because I learn a lot

That's it!

Congratulations for unlocking a new skill today ! :) Take care. See you on our next lesson.