Engineering and Genetics

Genetic Engineering Debate

By Mr. Frommelt

Here is how the debate will work...

• I will present the Quizizz slide and you will first take a minute to respond on Quizizz

• Next, I will ask who is for or against the idea

• I will then allow three people, on each side, the chance to state why the believe that side

• I will open the floor for a quick discussion

• You will get points for today by either being one of the side representative or by voicing your opinion in the open forum

IF YOU DO NOT ABIDE BY THE RULES:

IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points. This counts as a Lab so it is a lot of points.

Here is the situation...

We, as a class, are going to be some of the first people to experience genetic engineering with CRISPR in our lifetime. We have been assembled before a court to answer questions from the Chief of the Genetic Engineering division about our views and how it will affect the rest of human history. The teacher will play the role as the Chief and moderate the discussions. Remember, these decisions will impact the rest of human history.

Poll

Should CRISPR be used to eradicate disease?

• Yes

• No

Hearing the Sides

REMINDER: IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points. This counts as a Lab so it is a lot of points.

Open Forum

Any last minute notes or ideas. IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points. This counts as a Lab so it is a lot of points.

Poll

Should CRISPR be used to eradicate disease BEFORE a child is born?

• Yes

• No

Hearing the Sides

REMINDER: IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Open Forum

Any last minute notes or ideas. IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Poll

Should CRISPR be a public tool or a private tool?

• Public Access

• Private Access

Hearing the Sides

REMINDER: IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Open Forum

Any last minute notes or ideas. IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Poll

What effects could widespread CRISPR use have?

• Mostly Positive effects

• Neutral effects

• Mostly Negative effects

Hearing the Sides

REMINDER: IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Open Forum

Any last minute notes or ideas. IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Poll

Where should we draw the line of who/what CRISPR can be used on?

• Organism within the endangered range

• Organisms, but not humanoids

• Humans but with restrictions

• Humans with no restrictions

• Other

Hearing the Sides

REMINDER: IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.

Open Forum

Any last minute notes or ideas. IF you speak out of turn or do not mute when requested, you WILL be kicked from the Meet and NOT get your participation points.