Rogerian and Toulmin Model of Argumentation

​Rogerian Argument

​By Ms. Torralva

​What is a Rogerian Argument?

​Rogerian Arguments find common ground between two opposing arguments and propose compromises to further along the agenda of both sides of the argument. The thesis statement is stated in your conclusion as you build up to it with adequate evidence. You start with your opponent's viewpoints, then parallel your proof with your side of the argument supported with facts—match category with category. Be open-minded, fair, and respectful to both sides. Neutrality and fairness are critical to the success of a Rogerian argument.

​What a Rogerian argument is not.

• A Rogerian argument is neither confrontational nor has an aggressive tone. The reason is that you will alienate half your audience if you show bias towards one side.

• Your thesis statement is not in the intro, so you don't show your hand early in your opinions.

• A Rogerian argument is not rigid and stubborn when sticking to one side.

​

​

ELA | 10.2

Open Ended

Write down in your own words what a Rogerian argument is in two to four sentences.

Open Ended

In your own words write what a Rogerian argument is not in two to four sentences.

Poll

I feel confident that I know what a Rogerian argument is and is not.

• No

• Somewhat

• Yes

​Group Activity

As a group, Analyze an argument to find each side's argument and come up with three compromises)​

Step 1: As a group, analyze an argumentative article.

Step 2: Identity what each side believes using parallel analysis.

Step 3: come up with three compromises.​

Subject | Subject

Some text here about the topic of discussion

​Mediator Police Officer

Judge Doctor

Jurer Therapist

Liason Friend

Secretary of State​

​In the future (Jobs)

​Listen to two friends arguing with opposing views and come up with a compromise that this fair to both.

​Presently

​How you can use a Rogerian argument.

Some text here about the topic of discussion

​The difficulties of a Rogerian argument

1. Being prideful in your own stance creates immediate bias (Pride goeth before the fall)

2. Holding to a stance too tightly and not wanting to be open enough.

3. Sometimes finding compromises between two sides can be very difficult to handle.

4. Emotions between two sides can cause a stressful transition.

Subject | Subject

Some text here about the topic of discussion

Multiple Select

What jobs can you do using the Rogerian argument?

• Liaison

• Secretary of State

• Friend

• Therapist

Multiple Choice

What can cause difficulties in a Rogerian argument?

• logos

• flexibility

• closed-minded

• creativity

​Individual activity

Answer the following questions as you create a short Rogerian argument.​

1. Pick a simple topic i.e. (Aliens are real vs. conspiracy)

2. Improvise three ​main points for each side.

3. Create ​one compromise.

4. Share with your table.​

Subject | Subject

Some text here about the topic of discussion