Collecting Data Review- Set 2

A company famous for its nacho-flavored corn chips has developed two new formulas, A and B, which they hope their customers will like even more than the original formula. To determine whether customers prefer one of the new formulas over the current nacho flavoring, a sample of 50 customers is obtained. Each customer tastes both formula A and formula B in a randomly assigned order and indicates which one they prefer more. Which of the following best describes this study?

• This study is not well designed because there is no replication. Each customer tasted the formulas only once.

• This study is not well designed because formulas A and B are not compared with the original formula.

• This study is not well designed because the sample may not have been randomly selected.

• This study is not well designed because each customer should taste the two new formulas in the same order.

• This study is not well designed because there is not enough replication with only 50 customers.

Thirty-six students at a local middle school were randomly selected to participate in a taste test to select a new menu item for a cafeteria. Each student was given a choice between the macaroni and cheese and the Cajun potato barrels. From the sample, 20 students selected macaroni and cheese and 16 students chose the Cajun potato barrels. Each student was asked to rate the item they chose on a scale from 1 (extremely dislike) to 9 (extremely like). Which of the following prevents this study from being a well-designed experiment?

• There was no replication because students did not eat both menu items.

• The treatments (new menu item) were not randomly assigned to the students.

• An item that is currently on the menu should have been used as a control.

• Students should not have been randomly selected.

• There were no problems, and the study was a well-designed experiment.

Diane wanted to demonstrate which pruning technique was best for controlling the growth of certain types of shrubs. She selected ten shrubs of the same type and randomly assigned each one to receive one of ten different pruning methods. Two weeks after pruning, she measured the regrowth, in inches, of the shrubs; the pruning method that minimized regrowth was recommended as the best method. Which of the following best describes why this is not a well-designed experiment?

• The shrubs were not randomly selected.

• Pruning methods were not randomly assigned to shrubs.

• Each pruning method was used on only one shrub.

• Each shrub did not receive all ten pruning methods.

• Only two treatments should be used in an experiment.

A researcher conducted a study investigating the effect of computer screen time on a person’s amount of REM sleep. The researcher randomly assigned 100 people into four groups. The first group was given 2 hours of computer screen time each day, the second group was given 4 hours each day, the third group was given 6 hours each day, and the fourth group was given 8 hours each day. The study was conducted for one week, and the amount of REM sleep for each person was measured. What is the explanatory variable in the study?

• The amount of REM sleep

• The amount of computer screen time

• The 100 people in the study

• The four groups in the study

• There is no explanatory variable because the study is observational.

A researcher randomly selected 30 people to participate in a study to investigate which of two materials, A or B, used in the heels of sneakers will last longer. The researcher is considering two design types for the study.

Design 1: Randomly assign 15 participants to wear sneakers with material A on their left feet and material B on their right feet. The remaining participants will wear sneakers with material B on their left feet and material A on their right feet.

Design 2: Randomly assign 15 participants to wear sneakers with material A on both feet and the remaining participants to wear sneakers with material B on both feet.

Which of the following best describes each design?

• Design 1 is a completely randomized design, and design 2 is a matched pairs design.

• Design 1 is a matched pairs design, and design 2 is a completely randomized design.

• Design 1 is a matched pairs design, and design 2 is a matched pairs design.

• Design 1 is a completely randomized design, and design 2 is a completely randomized design.

• Design 1 is a completely randomized design, and design 2 is a randomized block with materials as blocks.

Tags

CCSS.HSS.IC.B.3

CCSS.HSS.IC.B.5

An experiment compared the adhesion of 2 types of paint, A and B, to 3 types of metal, 1, 2, and 3, used in automobiles. Thirty sheets of metal were used in the experiment: 10 of Metal 1, 10 of Metal 2, and 10 of Metal 3. Half of each metal type will receive paint A and the other half will receive paint B. The adhesion of the paints was measured, and the measures were compared. How many experimental units are in the experiment?

• 2

• 3

• 10

• 30

• 60

The two graduates with the greatest GPA from each of 14 randomly selected law schools were recruited to investigate a new method of preparation for a law exam. For each school, one student was randomly assigned to prepare using the standard method and the other student was assigned to prepare using the new method. At the end of the preparation, all 28 students were given the same exam, and their scores were recorded.

Which of the following best describes why a matched-pairs design is an appropriate design for the investigation?

• Each graduate was randomly assigned to one method.

• The law schools were randomly selected.

• Each method served as a block.

• The sample size was less than 30.

• Each law school served as a block, and the graduates were paired within each law school and randomly assigned to one of the two methods.

Tags

CCSS.HSS.IC.B.5

A pottery school wants to study whether the glaze of stoneware bowls is affected by the temperature used to harden the bowls. The study will use 3 different types of clay because glaze can affect different clay in different ways. Eight bowls will be made with each clay type for a total of 24 bowls, and 4 different temperatures will be used. What is the best design to use for the study?

• A completely randomized design. Randomly assign temperatures so that 6 bowls are glazed at each temperature.

• A completely randomized design. Randomly assign temperatures so that 2 bowls of each clay type are glazed at each temperature.

• A randomized block design. Randomly assign temperatures so that 6 bowls are glazed at each temperature.

• A randomized block design. Randomly assign temperatures so that 2 bowls of each clay type are glazed at each temperature.

• A matched pairs design. Randomly assign temperatures so that 2 bowls of each clay type are glazed at each temperature.

Tags

CCSS.HSS.IC.B.3

CCSS.HSS.IC.B.5

To investigate the effectiveness of an herbal medication for pain relief, a researcher randomly selected 80 patients who were undergoing physical therapy while recovering from an injury. Of the patients, 40 had knee injuries, 16 had arm injuries, and 24 had foot injuries. The researcher will use two treatments for the investigation: the herbal medication and a standard medication. After the patients are on the medication for two weeks, the amount of pain reduction will be measured for each patient. Which of the following best describes why a randomized block design is appropriate for the investigation?

• The 80 patients were selected at random from all patients undergoing physical therapy while recovering from an injury.

• The sample size was greater than 30.

• Each patient will be randomly assigned to either the herbal medication or the standard medication.

• Blocking on injury type will help to separate natural variability from differences due to injury type.

• Each patient assigned to the herbal medication will be paired with a patient assigned to the standard medication.

A professor at a large university plans to conduct a study to compare the effect of online texts versus regular printed texts on student learning. If the findings are to be generalized to all students at the university, which of the following must be part of the design?

• The students in the study should have experience using online and regular texts.

• The students in the study should be a random sample from the population of students at the university.

• The students should be allowed to choose which type of text they would like to use so that different learning styles are taken into consideration.

• The professor should collect data from all students in the population before generalizing results.

• Only volunteer students should be used in the study because they are more likely to be active participants.