Counterclaims & Rebuttals

A rebuttal is

• An argument made against someone else’s original argument.

• The main point or claim.

• The reason that supports the claim.

• An explanation as to why the opposing side of the argument is wrong.

Some people may think we should continue using large quantities of plastic as plastic wrapping can protect the quality of a product.

This is an example of:

• a rebuttal

• a counterclaim

Which statement opposes the following claim?

Cell phones are beneficial for teenagers.

• Cell phones are extremely helpful for most teenagers.

• Cell phones are distracting for teenagers.

• It should be illegal for people under 18 to have a cell phone.

• Cell phones have benefits and costs.

A counterclaim is

• An argument made against someone else’s original argument.

• The main point or claim.

• The reason that supports the claim.

• An explanation as to why the opposing side of the argument is wrong.

Why do we include counterclaims?

• To anticipate the argument from the opposing side

• To show what you know and strengthen your argument

• To prevent bias

• All of the above

You should include _____ with your rebuttal to make it stronger.

What would be a good rebuttal to the counterclaim, "Some people might think that smoking can help relieve stress."

• Smoking causes people to have bad breath, yellow teeth, and wrinkly skin.

• Smoking is bad for people.

• However, the medical bills and health problems that come from smoking would cause more stress.

• Smoking is expensive.

What is the underlined section? College athletes should be paid. Some might argue that a free education is a kind of payment, but the athletes still need money for food, medical bills, and entertainment.

• Claim

• Counterclaim

• Rebuttal

What's the rebuttal in the following statement: Some argue that Coke has better products; however, Pepsi sells more.

• Some argue that Coke has better products

• however, Pepsi sells more

Parents should be fined when their
children bully because it will send a
message. Some say It is very difficult for
parents to manage their children
when they leave the house and go to
school. Despite this, thirteen million
kids are bullied each year and
something needs to be done. The fines
will encourage parents to focus on anti-bullying in the home.
Which sentence is the counterclaim?

• Despite this, thirteen million
  kids are bullied each year and
  something needs to be done.
• The fines
  will encourage parents to
  focus on anti-bullying in the home.
• Some say it is very difficult for
  parents to manage their children
  when they leave the house and go to
  school.
• Parents should be fined when their
  children bully because it will send a
  message.