Cell Phone Discussion for 8th grade Argument Unit

Do you have your own cell phone?

• Yes.

• Nope. My parents won't let me yet.

• No, but for other reasons. It is not because my parents won't allow it.

• I would rather not say.

Do you think cell phones have a negative impact on student learning?

• Yes! Most kids are distracted by them.

• It depends on the student.

• No.

• I am not sure.

Finish this statement: Cell phones are beneficial to students at school because.......

True or False?

A 2017 study showed that even when students had phones in their pockets and didn't check them, they performed worse on memory tests. Researchers thought it caused "brain drain" even being in a student pocket.

• TRUE

• FALSE

According to the Pew Research Center, a median of 67% of people surveyed in 11 major countries believe that cell phones have been positive for education.

• True

• False

According to the Pew Research Center, 50% of parents limit their own cell phone use and their children's usage.

Do you think parents (not teachers) should be in charge of their children's cell phone use at school?

• Yes. Parents can decide what they want their kids to have and use at school.

• Maybe, but I am not sure.

• No. I think teachers can decide what happens at school.

• I think students should decide.

Do you think you use your phone too much?

• Yes.

• No.

• Maybe. I am on it a lot but it is hard to know what is "too much".

• Sometimes. It depends on how busy I am and what is going on in my life.

Several studies have shown that cell phone use in schools improves:

1.) engagement and focus

2.) digital access to information

3.) instant feedback and class discussions

(Himmelsbach, 2019; Ortiz & Green, 2019; Synnott, 2012)

Do you agree? How do cell phones help you learn?

During lunchtime, most kids have their heads down and are on their phones. Do you think this contributes to more students feeling depressed? Explain.

A 2016 study found that cell phone use is correlated with depression in adolescents, especially girls. Why do you think this is?