Gittin Quiz 15

What contradiction does the Gemara ask between the Mishna and the Bereisa?

• The Mishna said that the 5 ladies are believed to say the husband died and the Bereisa sys they're not believed.

• The Mishna said that the 5 ladies are not believed to say the husband died and the Bereisa sys they're believed.

• The Mishna said that the 5 ladies are believed to bring a Gett and the Bereisa sys they're not believed.

• The Mishna said that the 5 ladies are not believed to bring a Gett and the Bereisa says they're believed.

How does R' Yosef (1st answer) answer the contradiction?

• Mishna-We rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett in EY.

  Bereisa-We don't rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett outside of EY

• Mishna-We rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett outside of EY.

  Bereisa-We don't rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett in EY

• Mishna-We rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett if they are honest

  Bereisa-We don't rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett if they aren't honest

• Mishna-We rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett in EY.

  Bereisa-We don't rely on the 5 ladies to bring the Gett in EY

What is the rationale behind R' Yosef's answer to the contradiction between the Mishna and Bereisa?

• In EY we need to rely on your words. Outside of EY we don't have to rely on your words

• In EY we don't need to rely on your words. Outside of EY we do have to rely on your words

• In EY there are more witnesses than outside EY

• In EY we are not afraid of the husband protesting but outside EY we are

What question does Abaye ask on R' Yosef?

• She should be believed more from outside of EY because she says befanai nechtav/nechtam

• It shouldn't make a difference if she comes from EY or outside of EY

• She should be believed less in EY because she can mess her over more

• She should be believed more in EY because she can mess her over more

if the husband protests that he never wrote the Gett, which is true if it was brought in EY?

• In EY we don't listen to him and she is asur to her old husband but not her new husband

• In EY we don't listen to him and she is asur to her new husband and her old husband

• In EY we listen to him and she is asur to her new husband but not her old husband

• In EY we listen to him and she is asur to her new husband and her old husband

if the husband protests that he never wrote the Gett, which is true if it was brought from outside EY?

• We don't listen to him and she is asur to her old husband but not her new husband

• We don't listen to him and she is asur to her new husband but not her old husband

• We listen to him and she is asur to her new husband but not her old husband

• We listen to him and she is asur to her new husband and her old husband

What was the Gemara trying to show from the Bereisa that proves that a lady can bring her own Gett from Chutz La'aretz? (What was the point of quoting this beraisa?)

• That the case in the mishna where the 5 ladies are believed was from in EY

• That the case in the mishna where the 5 ladies are believed was from outside EY

• That the lady must say BNBN when she brings a Gett from outside EY

• That the lady doesn't need to say BNBN when she brings a Gett from outside EY

What was R' Ashi's proof to Abaye from the Mishna?

• It says in the Mishna that if the husband protests, he can't mess her up

• It says in the Mishna that if the husband protests, he can mess her up

• It says in the Mishna that the wife can bring her Gett if she says BNBN

• It says in the Mishna that the 5 ladies have to say BNBN when they bring the Gett

What was the Gemara's question on R' Ashi from the previous Mishna?

• We see that the problem with the blind person is not being able to say BNBN

• We see that the 5 ladies are not mentioned in that Mishna as a shliach

• We see that the 5 ladies are not able to testify about the husband being dead

• We see that if you start and end with Daas, you can be a shliach

What is R' Yosef's Diyuk from our Mishna that the case is talking about bringing the Gett in EY?

• Because it says that the 5 ladies are believed to bring the Gett and they are only believed in EY

• Because the last case is talking out outside EY which implies that the 1st case in in EY

• Because it doesn't list BNBN as a difference between testifying about death vs the Gett

• Because the only problem with a blind person bringing the Gett is that he can't say BNBN