Analyzing Conflicting Texts

Analyze the following two texts about climate change. Text A claims that human activities are the primary cause of climate change, while Text B argues that natural cycles are the main contributors. What is the main point of disagreement between the two texts?

• The role of technology in climate change

• The primary cause of climate change

• The impact of climate change on wildlife

• The economic effects of climate change

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Consider two articles discussing the effects of social media on teenagers. Article 1 states that social media enhances communication skills, while Article 2 suggests it leads to social isolation. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The impact of social media on education

• The effect of social media on communication skills

• The role of social media in entertainment

• The influence of social media on family relationships

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Two historians provide different interpretations of the causes of the American Civil War. Historian A emphasizes economic factors, while Historian B focuses on political tensions. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The role of slavery in the Civil War

• The economic impact of the Civil War

• The primary cause of the Civil War

• The influence of foreign nations on the Civil War

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Read two scientific articles about the health benefits of a vegetarian diet. Article X claims it reduces the risk of heart disease, while Article Y argues it may lead to nutritional deficiencies. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The environmental impact of a vegetarian diet

• The health benefits of a vegetarian diet

• The cost-effectiveness of a vegetarian diet

• The cultural acceptance of a vegetarian diet

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Evaluate two reports on the effectiveness of online learning. Report 1 states it improves student engagement, while Report 2 claims it decreases student motivation. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The accessibility of online learning

• The effectiveness of online learning

• The cost of online learning

• The technological requirements of online learning

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Two articles discuss the impact of urbanization on wildlife. Article A argues it leads to habitat destruction, while Article B suggests it creates new habitats. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The economic benefits of urbanization

• The impact of urbanization on wildlife

• The role of urbanization in climate change

• The cultural effects of urbanization

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Analyze two essays on the role of technology in education. Essay 1 claims technology enhances learning experiences, while Essay 2 argues it distracts students. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The cost of technology in education

• The role of technology in education

• The accessibility of technology in education

• The environmental impact of technology in education

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Two studies provide conflicting information about the effects of video games on children. Study A suggests they improve cognitive skills, while Study B claims they increase aggression. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The popularity of video games among children

• The effects of video games on children

• The economic impact of the video game industry

• The role of video games in education

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Consider two articles about renewable energy. Article 1 states it is the most sustainable energy source, while Article 2 argues it is not yet reliable enough. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The cost of renewable energy

• The sustainability of renewable energy

• The reliability of renewable energy

• The environmental impact of renewable energy

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9

Two reports discuss the impact of tourism on local cultures. Report A claims it promotes cultural exchange, while Report B argues it leads to cultural erosion. What is the main point of disagreement?

• The economic benefits of tourism

• The impact of tourism on local cultures

• The environmental effects of tourism

• The role of tourism in global development

Tags

CCSS.RI.8.9