Hasocher 82B Quiz

What is the halacha in the Mishna if you move your friends barrel in your house and it breaks?

• Shomer Sachar swears and shomer chinam is chayav

• Shomer Chinam swears and shomer sachar is chayav

• Both shomer sachar and shomer chinam swear

• Both shomer sachar and shomer chinam are chayav

What was R' Elazar wondering about?

• If tripping is considered negligence

• Why shomer chinam and shomer sachar can swear for moving a barrel and breaking it

• Why shomer chinam and shomer sachar have to pay for moving a barrel and breaking it

• If you are allowed to move a barrel of your friend without permission

What is R' Yehuda (in the Bereisa) opinion about moving a barrel from place to place that breaks?

• Shomer chinam swears and shomer sachar pays

• Shomer chinam pays and shomer sachar swears

• both swear

• both pay

From R' Meir saying that you are not responsible for the barrel breaking in the bereisa, what does that seem to show about his opinion?

• That a shomer is chayav for Ones

• That he holds tripping isn't negligence

• That he holds tripping is negligence

• That a shomer may not move a barrel without permission

How did we prove from another Bereisa that R' Meir holds that tripping is considered negligence?

• He says that if you fall and someone trips on your jug, you are chayav

• He says that if you fall and someone trips on your jug, you are patur

• He said that if you move your friends barrel and it breaks you are chayav

• He said that if you lead a camel up a mountain and it slips, you are chayav for the camel

The contradiction in R' Meir's opinion is about whether he holds _________ is considered to be negligence or not

How does R' Elazar (1st answer) answer the contradiction in R' Meir?

• There's a difference between camels and barrels

• The 1st Bereisa is't talking about tripping

• The 2nd Beriesa isn't talking about tripping

• There are 2 opinions about what R' Meir holds

Why didn't R' Eliezer understand (1st reason) why both shomrim can swear and be patur for breaking the barrel in the mishna?

• Because a shomer sachar should be chayav even if it was not negligence to trip

• Because there is no reason to swear for moving a barrel

• He feels that tripping is negligence so you should be chayav

• He feels that the ownerof the arrel should swear and not the shomer

When does R Eliezer feel a Shomer Chinam should be chayav for breaking the barrel?

• If he tripped on an incline

• If he tripped on level ground

• If he picked it up to look at it

• none of the above

In what case does R' Eliezer say that a shomer chinam doesn't swear even if it was an Ones?

• If he picked it up to look at it.

• if he slipped on level ground

• If he slipped on an incline

• If there were witnesses that saw what happened