'Call Me by Your Name,' 'The Post' and More Films Reviewed in Brutally Honest Oscar Ballot | THR News

An anonymous Oscar voter shares candid opinions on various films and performances of the season. The voter criticizes 'Call Me by Your Name' for its portrayal of age difference, 'The Post' for being over-directed by Spielberg, and 'Three Billboards' for lacking authenticity. While appreciating 'Lady Bird', the voter criticizes its social media campaign. The voter praises 'Phantom Thread' and 'The Shape of Water' for their unique storytelling. In the Best Actor category, the voter supports Gary Oldman despite past allegations. The Hollywood Reporter invites readers to share their thoughts.

What was the anonymous Oscar voter's main criticism of 'Call Me by Your Name'?

• The storyline was too predictable.

• The cinematography was lacking.

• The age difference portrayal seemed inappropriate.

• The acting was subpar.

How did the voter feel about Steven Spielberg's direction in 'The Post'?

• It lacked emotional depth.

• It was innovative and refreshing.

• It was too similar to 'Birdman'.

• It was overdone and distracting.

What was the voter's opinion on the film 'Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri'?

• The direction was confusing.

• The story felt inauthentic.

• The acting was poor.

• The film was too long.

Which film did the voter praise for its unique storytelling?

• Phantom Thread

• Call Me by Your Name

• Lady Bird

• The Post

What was the voter's stance on Gary Oldman's performance in 'Darkest Hour'?

• It was overshadowed by his personal controversies.

• It was overrated by critics.

• It was not as impressive as other nominees.

• It was outstanding despite past allegations.