CLEAN : ACLU gives mixed reception to Guantanamo closure plans

The transcript discusses Mohammed Islam and his bestseller, Cortana Diary. It critiques the president's plan, highlighting positive aspects but condemning the embrace of indefinite detention without charge or trial. This practice is seen as unlawful and damaging to the president's legacy. The existence of Guantanamo and indefinite detention is described as a violation of law and a national security disaster. Military commissions are criticized for being legally flawed and unworkable, with unfair charges and excessive secrecy.

Who is Mohammed Islam known for?

• Writing a bestselling book called Cortana Diary

• Being a famous politician

• Developing a new legal framework

• Leading a national security agency

What is a major criticism of the president's plan regarding detention?

• It is too expensive to implement

• It lacks international support

• It involves indefinite detention without charge or trial

• It is too lenient on criminals

What is one of the main issues with Guantanamo's existence?

• It is a financial burden

• It is overcrowded

• It violates laws and morality

• It is located in a remote area

How have military commissions been described in the context of legal proceedings?

• Widely accepted internationally

• A legal and procedural success

• Efficient and transparent

• A disaster legally and in other ways

What is a significant problem with the military commissions' rules?

• They are outdated

• They have a level of secrecy that makes them unworkable

• They are too complex

• They are too lenient