Effective Critique Techniques

The video tutorial by Shaylen from Reed Z covers how to critique writing effectively. It begins with an introduction to the topic, followed by a discussion on basic etiquette in critiquing, emphasizing the importance of being timely, avoiding unsolicited feedback, and respecting the writer's requests. The tutorial then delves into how to be respectful and helpful in critiques, offering practical advice on providing constructive feedback without overstepping boundaries. The video concludes with final tips and a reminder not to replace professional editors.

What is the primary focus of the video tutorial?

• How to edit a manuscript

• How to publish a book

• How to critique writing

• How to write a novel

What is the first rule of critiquing etiquette mentioned?

• Be critical

• Be silent

• Be creative

• Be timely

Why should you avoid giving unsolicited critique?

• It is a waste of time

• It can be seen as condescending

• It can be seen as helpful

• It is always appreciated

What should you do if a writer asks for only developmental edits?

• Ignore their request

• Focus on grammar

• Respect their request

• Provide line edits

What is a key aspect of being respectful in critiques?

• Imposing your own story ideas

• Making moral judgments on characters

• Letting go of personal expectations

• Criticizing the author's choices

Why should you avoid making moral judgments on characters?

• It may not align with the author's intention

• It is always wrong

• It is not part of critiquing

• Characters must be morally pure

What is a recommended ratio of positive feedback to criticism?

• Half positive, half negative

• One third positive, two thirds criticism

• All positive

• All criticism

How can you make your feedback more respectful?

• Focus only on criticism

• Avoid giving feedback

• Use positive phrasing

• Use negative phrasing

What should you aim to explain in a helpful critique?

• Why something isn't working

• What isn't working

• Who wrote the piece

• When it was written

How can you make criticism sound kinder?

• By ignoring the writer's feelings

• By focusing on grammar

• By being vague

• By explaining how problems impede strengths