Worksheetsמתקיף לה רמי בר חמא
Total questions: 17
Worksheet time: 9mins
What is the חידוש of our משנה?
If the watchman pays he gets the extra payments.
If the watchman wants, he can swear and not need to pay.
A שומר חנם is not obligated for stolen objects.
A cow that is stolen or slaughtered, the thief pays 5 times the value of the cow.
What is רמי בר חמא's question?
Why isn't the שומר חנם responsible for stolen items?
Does the שומר חנם need to pay?
How can you buy the extra payments, you're getting more than you paid for?
How can you buy the extra payments, they don't exist yet?
What is the possible attempted answer to רמי בר חמא's question?
You can sell extra payments because it really belongs to the תורה.
You can sell the extra payments because you can't expect for them to materialize.
You can sell the extra payments according to ר מאיר.
You can sell the extra payments when it is very important for the owner to get his money back.
What is רמי בר חמא's knock off to the attempted answer to his question?
ר מאיר was being misquoted and he doesn't hold that.
ר מאיר only says that you can buy something that doesn't exist if you can expect it but here you can't.
ר מאיר only says that you can buy something that doesn't exist if you have no other way to recover your money, but here you can find the thief.
ר מאיר only says that you can buy something that doesn't exist if you make it clear that there is no backsies, but here there was no mention of that.
What factors make our משנה not a case of עבידי דאתו?
Perhaps the item will not be stolen.
Perhaps the court system will be unjust.
Perhaps the thief will admit to stealing and will not need to pay any extra payments.
Perhaps there will be a way to disqualify the witnesses.
Perhaps the thief will not be apprehended.
What is רבא's answer to רמי בר חמא's question?
Our משנה can be expected because those concerns are not likely.
Our משנה thinks that the extra payments are already considered existing.
You are buying the cow.
You are buying only the shearings and offspring.
What is רבי זירא's question on רבא's answer?
The משנה says you are buying the extra payments.
A ברייתא says you are buying the extra payments.
The משנה says that you don't get the shearings and offspring and you will say that you do.
The ברייתא says that you don't get the shearings and offspring and you will say that you do.
What was רבי זירא's answer to רמי בר חמא's question?
You are buying the byproducts.
You are buying the cow minus the byproducts.
You are buying the extra payments directly.
You are buying the cow.
מתקיף
Answer
Proof
Question
Disproof
אין אדם מקנה דבר שלא בא לעולם
A person can sell anything
A person can sell his future objects.
A person can not sell something that doesn't exist.
A person doesn't want to sell something until it exists.
עבידי דאתו
Common
Coming soon
Working
Expected
מגנבא
Lost
Destroyed
Stolen
Broken
מודי
Admit
Deny
Thank
Want
מעכשיו
From then
From now
To then
To now
תניא
Taught in a ברייתא
Taught in a משנה
Taught in the תורה
Taught in the גמרא
What is the גמרא's two word question on רבי זירא's answer?
מאי נפקא מינה
מאי איכא למימר
מאי פסקא
היכי פסקינן
What was the גמרא's question on רבי זירא's answer?
How can you sell an animal minus its byproducts?
Why would the owner sell the extra payments but not the byproducts?
How can you own just the byproducts?
How, then, did the ברייתא know that you're not selling the byproducts?
