NEW
Font size
Worksheetsgemara hilnei
Total questions: 12
Worksheet time: 6mins
The gemara starts off with somebody proving a halacha regarding a sukkah, who is that somebody?
chachamim
Rebbi Yehuda
Hilni
Rebbi Klein
Rebbi Yehuda proves from the fact that:
The zekeinim didn't say anything to her
The zikeinim DID say something to her
Her sukkah was lower than 20 amos
אמרו לו משם ראייה, Who's talking?
Rebbi Yehuda
chachamim
Rabbi Klein
Hilni
Rebbi Yehuda first answer back:
הלא שבעה בנים הוו
ועוד כל מעשיה לא עשתה אלא על פי חכמים
כשרה
למה לי למיתני ועוד כל מעשיה לא עשתה אלא על פי חכמים Means:
The gemara is trying to clarify what Rebbi Yehuda said
The gemara is answering a question
The gemara is saying a contradiction
הכי קאמר להו means:
This is what he meant to say
I don't believe it
I believe it
We DON'T believe it
Rebbi Yehuda says even if Hilni is patur her:
children are chayav
children aren't chayav
she is chayav medirabanon
she isn't chayav medirabanon
What does chinuch mean?
teaching your students
honoring your parents
making the proper blessing after meals
educating a child under Bar mitzvah
אי אפשר means:
It's possible
It's impossible
There is a
It could be
When the gemara says אי אפשר, it means:
It's impossible that at least one child wouldn't be above the age of chinuch
It's impossible that she had seven sons
It's possible that all her sons were under five
When the gemara says, כי תימרו קטן שאינו צריך לאמו מדרבנן הוא דמיחייב ואיהי בדרבנן לא משגחה :
It is asking that maybe Hilni didn't listen to mitzvos from the rabanan
It is asking maybe HIlni did listen to all the mitzvos dirabanan
It is asking maybe Hilni didn't know the halacha
At the end of the day, Rebbi Yehuda says:
ת"ש ועוד כל מעשיה לא עשתה אלא ע"פ חכמים hilni did listen to rabbanans
ת"ש ועוד כל מעשיה לא עשתה אלא ע"פ חכמים she didnt listen to rabbanans
ת"ש ועוד כל מעשיה לא עשתה אלא ע"פ חכמים she was a nice queen
