NEW
Font size
WorksheetsBava Kamma Review Assignment - Track 2
Total questions: 22
Worksheet time: 2hrs 50mins
What was the רישא/first case of the Mishnah?
A person trips on a barrel and breaks it in רשות היחיד
A person trips on a barrel and injures themself in רשות הרבים
The entire street is filled with barrels and blocked off
A person trips on a barrel and breaks it in רשות הרבים
According to the ORIGINAL understanding of the Mishnah (before the אוקימתא's), who pays for the broken barrel?
The owner
The tripper
Both
The tripper, if it happened during the day
What was the סיפא/second case of the Mishnah?
A person trips on a barrel and injures themself in רשות היחיד
A person trips on a barrel and injures themself in רשות הרבים
The entire street is filled with barrels and blocked off
A person trips on a barrel and breaks it in רשות הרבים
According to the ORIGINAL understanding of the Mishnah, who pays for the tripper's accidental injuries?
The owner
The tripper
Both
The tripper, he should have looked where he was going
What does this line in the Gemara mean? אמאי פטור? איבעי ליה לעיוני ומיזל!
Why is he obligated? He should have looked where he was going?
Why is he exempt? He should have looked where he was going?
People don't usually look where they are going!
This answer does not work with the Mishnah.
What is the function of this line: אמאי פטור? איבעי ליה לעיוני ומיזל!
Question/Challenge
Answer
אוקימתא
Introducing a ברייתא
In this line: איבעי ליה לעיוני ומיזל, who is the Gemara asking about? Who should have looked where he was going and therefore pay for the jug?
Owner
Tripper
Both
No one
According to all 3 rabbis, in a regular case (where he could have looked), who would have to pay for the broken jug?
The owner
The tripper
Both
Neither
Who says the Mishnah was ONLY talking about a case where it was night (in that situation, it's the owner's fault and he pays)
Rav
Shmuel
R' Yochanan
Rav Papa
Who says the Mishnah was ONLY talking about a case where the whole street was filled with barrels (in that situation, it's the owner's fault and he pays)
Rav
Shmuel
R' Yochanan
Rav Papa
Whose answer does not work with the Mishnah?
Rav
R' Yochanan
Shmuel
Rav Pappa
What word in the Mishnah does not make sense with Rav's answer?
כד
עיוני
נתקל
שבר
Why does the word נתקל in the Mishnah not work with Rav's answer? What INCORRECT assumption does it imply?
If the whole street was blocked with barrels, you are only פטור if you break them by accident - which is not true.
If the whole street was blocked with barrels, you are פטור if you break them on purpose - which is not true.
If the whole street is blocked with barrels, can you break them ON PURPOSE to clear a path?
Yes - the owner can't block the road
No - you must ask permission
Only if it's during the day
Only if the owner forgot about the barrel
What is the word נתקל really coming to teach us?
A new law for the רישא of the Mishnah
A new law for the סיפא of the Mishnah
What new law does the word נתקל teach us?
Owner only pays for tripper's injuries if he broke barrel on purpose, not by accident
Owner only pays for tripper's injuries if he broke barrel by accident, and not on purpose
The owner always pays for the tripper's injuries no matter what
Look where you are going when you walk on the street!
What is Tosafot's question?
Why does the Gemara only ask a question (he should have looked!) on the רישא?
Why does the Gemara only ask a question (he should have looked!) on the סיפא?
According to Tosafot, we are ALWAYS held more responsible when we do what?
Break stuff
Hurt a person
Block a road
Don't look where we are going
What does the word מערבא mean?
In the West - in Israel
In the West - in Bavel
In the East - in Bavel
In the East - in Israel
Does Ullah agree with the Gemara's original question - איבעי ליה לעיוני ומיזל - the tripper should have looked where he was going (and pay)?
Yes - Ullah believes ppl need to look where they are going
No - Ullah believes people don't pay attention when they are going.
What does the opinion of Ullah mean? שאין דרכן של בני אדם להתבונן בדרכים
You have to look where you are going!
People don't usually look where they are going when they are walking
You can't block roads completely
You can't injure other people
Which opinion is NOT like the others (when it comes to who pays for the broken jug)?
Rav
R' Yochanan
Shmuel
Ullah
