NEW
Font size
Worksheetsאין אונס בגיטין
Total questions: 8
Worksheet time: 6mins
According to Rava, when a man comes late (after 12 months) and claims that he was sick in hospital and that's why he did not come before the deadline,
the Get is not valid
the Get is valid
the Get is neither valid or invalid
Rava's ruling, then, is
אין אונס בגיטין
יש אונס בגיטין
אין גט לאחר מיתה
The Gemara asks מנא ליה לרבא הא? This means:
How does he know the diyuk is valid?
Why did Rava disagree with the baraita?
Where did Rava get his halacha from?
The Gemara answers: He learned it...
from a mishna in which a man says to his wife, "This is your Get after I die" - it's as if he didn't say anything לא אמר כלום
from a mishna in which a man says to his wife, "This is your Get if I die from this illness"- that is considered a Get
from a mishna in which a man says to his wife, "This is your Get if I don't return within 12 months - and he comes late and claims אונס" - it is a good Get
from a mishna in which a man says to his wife, "This is your Get if I don't return within 12 months - and he comes late and claims אונס" - it is NOT a good Get
from a mishna in which a man says to his wife, "This is your Get if I don't return within 12 months - and he dies - it is NOT a good Get
The Gemara questions Rava's diyuk/inference, but pointing out that the author of the mishna may have...
just been teaching אין גט לאחר מיתה and may hold יש אונס בגיטין
just been teaching יש גט לאחר מיתה and may hold אין אונס בגיטין
just been teaching אין גט לאחר מיתה and may hold איו אונס בגיטין
Rava's camp answers: It can't be that the Tanna of the mishna is just teaching אין גט לאחר מיתה, because
no Tanna holds like that anyhow
no Amora holds like that anyhow
אין גט לאחר מיתה was already taught in an earlier mishna so teaching it again is unnecessary
This Tanna really holds יש גט לאחר מיתה
Therefore, the 12-month mishna where he dies must be teaching
אין אונס בגיטין
יש אונס בגיטין
אין גט לאחר מיתה
יש גט לאחר מיתה
If a husband says הרי זה גיטיך מעכשיו אם מתי
It's considered a גט לאחר מיתה
It's not considered a גט לאחר מיתה
