Which criterion is observed when your chosen information was interpreted without any bias?

Which criterion is observed when your chosen information is still commonly known, in use or accepted?

Which criterion is observed when you chose information based on its reliability and correctness?

Which criterion is observed when the author of your chosen information has the qualifications to write on that specific topic?

“This paper is a little too outdated. This won’t do.”

“This does not go along with my research topic. I won’t need this.

“This paper has just been conducted last year. This suits my study.”

“This paper went through a peer evaluation. This must be a thorough research.”

“Upon reading the title, I thought it is relevant to my study, but as I read on, it is not.”

“I have read the qualifications of this author and he is a doctor. I will include this.”

“The results of this research were also proven in the previous research I read. I will include this.

“I wonder why the conclusion of this research was not congruent to his results. I will discard this.”

“This study was conducted in the late 90s. This does no longer apply in today’s world. I will look for another.”

Oh, this education-related research was conducted by a professor emeritus from Harvard University. This shall go on my list.”