WorksheetsGemara Hakones - Sugya 9c
Total questions: 17
Worksheet time: 19mins
who said a שומר אבידה is like a שומר שכר
רבה
רבא
ר׳ יוסף
ר׳ יהודה
who said a שומר אבידה is like a שומר חנם
רבה
רבא
ר׳ יוסף
ר׳ יהודה
MATCH
איתיביה: לעולם הוא חייב עד שיחזירנה לרשותוֹ מאי לעולם? לאו אפילו מביתו, ש״מ: כשומר שכר דמיִ
Our challenge is against (a)
לעולם הוא חייב עד שיחזירנה לרשות
Explain how this ברייתא challenges him:
when it says “you are responsible until to return it” seems like if it gets stolen you are responsible
when it says “you are responsible until to return it” seems like if it gets stolen you are not responsible for it
when it sats “forever” you can learn that you are responsible for it because hashem is also “forever” watching you
its a challenge because it says the word עד and when every it says עד its a proof like a witness (עד)
What number proof is this?
Where dose one need to return a lost object to
The place he found it
To the owner
He can keep it no need to return it
The torah dose not tell us
One (a) take care of a lost object until he finds the owner
Dose the gemara know for sure the Halacha if someone found a lost object and it got stolen
Yes
No its a machlokes
EC: What is a שומר?
A guard
A barber
a judge
a seller
EC: What is the plural of שומר?
שמורים
שומין
השומר
שומר
שומרם
(a) is the main subject of our mesechta
why is Reb Yossef saying a ברייתא to רבה
for fun
to prove his opinion
to show off
to show how רבה is right
Why are we speaking about different שומרים in our gemara?
Which mesechta are we leaning now and which perek?
מסכת
בבא
קמא
פרק
הכונס
What is רבה and ר יוסף trying to figure out?
what is the price of rice in china
what Is the halcha if a lost object got stolen
what Is the halcha If a cow damaged a field
how much is ten zuz
What came first mishna of gemara? (a)
