Hameiniach 1

Front

What is the first case of our Mishna? Options: Someone trips over a jug in the street and breaks it, Someone slips on a puddle in the street, Someone purposely kicks a jug in the street

Back

Someone trips over a jug in the street and breaks it

Front

Does the pedestrian have to pay for the jug?

Back

No

Front

What does that halacha seem to indicate about whether you have to watch where you're going in the street?

Back

You're NOT responsible to watch where you're going

Front

What does the Gemara assert about watching where you're going in the street?

Back

You MUST watch where you're going, and you ARE liable for damage you cause

Front

What is the kasha, based on that assertion?

Back

How could the Mishna say the pedestrian is patur?

Front

How does the Gemara structurally try to answer the kasha?

Back

By making ukimtas (saying the Mishna is about a specific exception case)

Front

What is the ukimta that Rav makes?

Back

The street was blocked by barrels

Front

In Rav's barrel case, is the pedestrian patur if he broke it on purpose, or only if it was an accident?

Back

Even on purpose

Front

Which of the following is true according to Rav? You must always watch where you're going, You're never liable if you don't watch where you're going, You must watch where you're going, if its possible to see, You must watch where you're going whenever reasonably possible

Back

You must always watch where you're going

Front

What ukimta does Shmuel make to explain the Mishna?

Back

The Mishna was talking about a case where it was dark outside