How to Critique

​“The Art of Critique”

Open Ended

What do you think critique is?

A critique is giving helpful feedback on someone’s work so they can make it better.

• Helps us grow as creators

• Improves projects through feedback

• Builds collaboration and communication skills

​Why Critique Matters

• Personal attacks

• Just “I like it” or “It’s bad”

• Only pointing out flaws

Critique IS NOT:

• Honest, thoughtful feedback

• About the work, not the person

• A tool for improvement

Critique IS:

What Critique Is (and Isn’t)

Two Sides of Critique

1. Giving Feedback – learning to analyze and express ideas clearly

2. Receiving Feedback – learning to listen, reflect, and improve

• Be specific: Point out exact moments or choices

• Be objective: Focus on techniques, not personal taste

• Be respectful: Assume the creator worked hard

​

How to Give Helpful Feedback

How to Receive Critique

• Listen without interrupting

• Take notes

• Don’t get defensive — feedback = growth

• Ask clarifying questions

• “One thing I noticed is…”

• “This choice helps because…”

• “You might make this stronger by…”

• “Have you thought about…?”

​

Critique Sentence Starters

• Respect each speaker

• Keep comments short and focused

• No computers during screening or critique

• Everyone participates

​

​In-Class Critique Norms

Multiple Choice

What are our critique norms?

• Respect each speaker

  Keep comments short and focused

  No computers during screening or critique

  Everyone participates

• Use the computer
  You can say whatever you want
  

1. Watch this short on the board. https://youtu.be/3OmLzOFWB3w?si=rPNK4GdJx0DA_rn2

2. Talk to your table mates and give one positive observation and one suggestion for improvement.

3. Be ready to share with the class.

​

​Practice Activity