יאוש שלא מדעת

What is יאוש שלא מדעת?

• When someone finds something before the owner knows he lost it

• When someone finds something after the owner gave up on it

Which אמוראים argue about יאוש שלא מדעת?

• אביי / רבא

• ר יהודה / ר ירמיה

What does אביי hold about יאוש שלא מדעת?

• It is not considered יאוש

• It is considered יאוש

What does רבא hold about יאוש שלא מדעת?

• It is not considered יאוש

• It is considered יאוש

In which TWO cases do Abaye and Rovo agree?

• Something that has a סימן

• Something that doesn't have a סימן

• Something swept away by a sea or river

What do both Abaye and Rovo hold about something that has a סימן?

• חייב להכריז (must announce)

• שלו (can keep)

What do both Abaye and Rovo hold about something swept away by a sea or river?

• חייב להכריז (must announce)

• שלו (can keep)

What is יאוש מדעת?

• When someone finds something before the owner knows he lost it

• When someone finds something after the owner gave up on it

8.00am - Shua loses ball

8.30am - Yossi finds it

9.00am - Shua realises his loss and gives up

What is this?

• יאוש שלא מדעת

• יאוש מדעת

8.00am - Shua loses ball

8.30am - Shua realises his loss and gives up

9.00am - Yossi finds it

What is this?

• יאוש שלא מדעת

• יאוש מדעת