New Succah Sugyah - Video 1 Assignment 1

What is the disagreement in the baraisa regarding a dry lulav (just the basic machlokes! - Who holds what?)

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

What does Rava limit the machlokes to? Where do Tanna Kamma/Chachamim disagree, and where do they agree?

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

Using this pasuk https://www.sefaria.org.il/Leviticus.23.41?vhe=Tanach_with_Ta%27amei_Hamikra&lang=he&aliyot=0, what's the reason for their machlokes?

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

What is the reason that they both agree that a dry esrog is pasul, invalid, based on the same pasuk?

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

The Gemara then begins to challenge R. Yehuda's view that a lulav does not need הדר/beauty. What source does the Gemara bring to prove that R. Yehuda holds that a lulav needs to be beautiful? Be specific with your quoting of the source and explain how this leads the Gemara to think that R. Yehuda requires hidur in lulav.

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

What does the Gemara say to deflect/push off this proof? Explain the logic of the Gemara's rejection of this attack question.

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF

Are we happy or sad at this point and why?

Evaluate responses using AI:

OFF