Hamfakid Sugya #7

How long does the שומא still go back according to Niharday 

• 6 months

• 12 months

• 12 years

Until when does the  שומא go bac according to Ameimar

• 6 months

• 12 months

• forever

Why does the שומא always go back?

• the pasuk says to do the right thing

• the person always had the money

• the item was not worth that much

If Joe owes Sam money, who is the   בַּעַל  חוֹב?

Translate שׁוּמָא הָדַר- The evaluation

Translate כִּיפִּי

Translate לֹא עָדִיף אַתְּ

• you are no better

• you are better

• the owner of the debt

If person 1 owes money to person 2 nad person 2 owes to person 3, can person 1 get his land back from person 3 if he comes up with the money?

• for sure no

• it is obvious yes

• machlokes

Why does person one get his land back from person 3?

• he doesnt

• he gave it directly to person 1

• person 3 is no better than person 2 who would need to give his land back

אַמְרִינָן לֵיה  

• we go

• we say to him

• he says