The Dilemma of Lying for a Friend's Date

What is the primary ethical dilemma presented in the text?

• Whether to tell Carey the correct time for dinner

• Whether to cancel the dinner reservation

• Whether Emerson is a suitable match for Carey

• Whether to invite more friends to the dinner

According to the text, how does Carey typically behave regarding punctuality?

• Carey prefers to meet in the morning instead of the evening.

• Carey is always on time for events.

• Carey arrives fashionably late, often by 20 to 30 minutes.

• Carey is known for being early to events.

What philosophical perspective does Immanuel Kant represent regarding lying?

• Lying can be justified if it leads to happiness.

• Lying is always wrong, regardless of the situation.

• Lying is a personal choice that depends on the individual.

• Lying is acceptable if it protects someone from harm.

How might a utilitarian philosopher like John Stuart Mill view the act of lying in this scenario?

• Lying is acceptable if it results in greater overall happiness.

• Lying is always immoral and should be avoided.

• Lying is only acceptable if it protects the liar.

• Lying should be avoided regardless of the consequences.

What potential consequence of lying to Carey is highlighted in the text?

• It could lead to a misunderstanding between Carey and Emerson.

• It might result in the cancellation of the dinner.

• It may cause Carey to be upset about the dinner.

• It could create a false impression of Carey's punctuality for Emerson.

What does the text suggest about the respect for independence in decision-making?

• It is more important to protect friends from bad decisions.

• Respecting independence means allowing individuals to make their own choices, even if they may not be ideal.

• Independence is irrelevant when it comes to relationships.

• Independence should be disregarded in favor of ensuring happiness.

In the conclusion, what key question remains unanswered regarding the dilemma?

• How can Carey and Emerson be introduced?

• What time should the dinner reservation be made for?

• What will the author decide to do in Carey's case?

• How can punctuality be improved in relationships?

What is the utilitarian view on lying according to John Stuart Mill?

• Lying is a personal choice that depends on the individual.

• Lying should be avoided regardless of the consequences.

• Lying is acceptable if it results in greater overall happiness.

• Lying is always wrong, regardless of the situation.

What does the text suggest about paternalism in the context of lying?

• Paternalism is acceptable for adults in all situations.

• Paternalism is always justified when it leads to happiness.

• Paternalism is irrelevant in ethical dilemmas.

• Paternalism can be disrespectful when applied to adults.

 Reflect on whether lying is right or wrong in this scenario. Do you believe that lying to Carey would help or harm the situation? Explain your reasoning in 2-3 sentences.