The Critique Challenge

The novel “Of Mice and Men” left me with mixed emotions about loyalty and difficult decisions. George’s choice at the end of the story made me wonder what I would do in the same situation. The relationship between George and Lennie felt both heartbreaking and inspiring. I found myself deeply affected by their friendship and struggles.

• FORMALISM

• READER RESPONSE

• MARXIST

• FEMINISM

Shakespeare’s “Sonnet 18” is crafted with careful attention to rhythm and rhyme, giving the poem a lyrical and timeless quality. The comparison of a loved one to a “summer’s day” is both simple and powerful, enhancing the subject’s beauty. Each line is meticulously structured to build admiration, while the closing couplet promises that the subject’s beauty will live on through the poem itself. The formal arrangement of words makes the poem feel eternal.

• FEMINISM

• READER RESPONSE

• FORMALISM

• MARXIST

“The Little Prince” invites readers to see the world through the eyes of a child, full of curiosity and imagination. The story reminded me of the importance of looking beyond material things and appreciating what truly matters. I found myself reflecting on the simple lessons about love and friendship that often get lost in adult life. It is a story that feels both innocent and profound at the same time.

• READER RESPONSE

• FORMALISM

• FEMINISM

• MARXIST

Vincent van Gogh’s “Starry Night” stands out because of its swirling brushstrokes and vibrant use of color, which seem to bring the night sky to life. The dark silhouette of the town contrasts strongly with the glowing stars and moon, creating a striking visual effect. Every curve and line in the painting appears deliberate, conveying both movement and calmness at the same time. The way the elements are arranged gives viewers an intense emotional experience.

• MARXIST

• FEMINISM

• READER RESPONSE

• FORMALISM

In the movie “Mulan,” the main character takes on challenges that others believe she cannot face because of her gender. She proves her strength, intelligence, and determination by succeeding in areas traditionally reserved for men. Her journey shows that bravery and skill are not determined by social expectations. This message of defying limitations inspires audiences to break stereotypes.

• FORMALISM

• READER RESPONSE

• MARXIST

• FEMINISM

In Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol,” the character of Scrooge represents the greed and selfishness of the wealthy elite. His lack of compassion for the poor contrasts sharply with the warmth and kindness of the Cratchit family. As he transforms, the story shows how generosity can bridge the divide between classes. It offers a reminder of the importance of kindness over materialism.

• FORMALISM

• FEMINISM

• MARXIST

• READER RESPONSE

George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” tells the story of animals rebelling against humans in search of equality. However, as the pigs rise to power, they become just as oppressive as their former rulers. This change shows how power can corrupt even the most well-meaning leaders. It serves as a warning about the dangers of unchecked authority.

• FEMINISM

• READER RESPONSE

• FORMALISM

• MARXIST

Pablo Picasso’s “Guernica” uses sharp angles, broken shapes, and distorted forms to evoke feelings of chaos and pain. The absence of color, relying solely on shades of black, gray, and white, heightens the sense of tragedy. Each figure in the painting appears to scream silently, reflecting suffering and destruction. The visual structure itself conveys the emotional weight of the event.

• READER RESPONSE

• FORMALISM

• MARXIST

• FEMINISM

Maya Angelou’s “Phenomenal Woman” is a celebration of confidence and self-acceptance. The speaker embraces her natural beauty and power without needing to conform to society’s narrow ideals. Each verse proudly declares that her strength and grace make her truly remarkable. The poem inspires women to value themselves for who they are.

• FORMALISM

• READER RESPONSE

• MARXIST

• FEMINISM

Reading “Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone” was like stepping into another world filled with magic and adventure. I could easily imagine myself as a student at Hogwarts, learning spells and exploring hidden rooms. The story filled me with excitement and wonder as if I were truly part of the journey. It made me appreciate the power of imagination.

• FORMALISM

• READER RESPONSE

• FEMINISM

• MARXIST