Understanding Judicial Rulings and Decision-Making

Understanding Judicial Rulings and Decision-Making

Assessment

Interactive Video

Social Studies, Business, Psychology

9th - 12th Grade

Hard

Created by

Emma Peterson

FREE Resource

The video discusses a 2011 study by researchers Danziger, Lavov, and Peso on how psychological factors affect judicial rulings. They analyzed over 1,000 Israeli parole court rulings and found that judges were more likely to reject cases later in a decision session, with favorable rulings dropping from 65% to nearly zero before a break. This phenomenon, known as the irrational hungry judge effect, suggests that judges make less effortful decisions when tired or hungry. The study's findings also apply to corporate leaders, who should avoid making decisions when mentally depleted.

Read more

7 questions

Show all answers

1.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

What was the primary focus of the study conducted by Shai Danziger and his team?

The influence of psychological factors on judicial rulings

The effect of media on public perception of judges

The impact of legal training on judges

The role of technology in court decisions

2.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

How many parole requests did the judges typically process in a day during the study?

10

15

20

25

3.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

What pattern was observed in the percentage of favorable rulings within each decision session?

It increased gradually

It dropped gradually to nearly zero

It fluctuated randomly

It remained constant

4.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

What was the percentage of favorable rulings after a break?

30%

50%

65%

80%

5.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

What was the main finding regarding the timing of parole request hearings?

Requests were randomly approved or rejected

Timing had no impact on the decision

Requests were more likely to be rejected later in the session

Requests were more likely to be approved later in the session

6.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

What is the 'irrational hungry judge effect'?

Judges favoring requests after a meal

Judges using complex strategies for decision-making

Judges rejecting requests due to mental depletion and hunger

Judges making decisions based on emotions

7.

MULTIPLE CHOICE QUESTION

30 sec • 1 pt

How does the 'irrational hungry judge effect' relate to corporate organizations?

Leaders should make decisions when tired

Leaders should rely on intuition

Leaders should avoid decision-making when hungry or mentally depleted

Leaders should delegate decisions to others