VOICED: French 'ministers court' under the spotlight

The video discusses the French Criminal Court, CJR, which tries government ministers for crimes committed during their official duties. It explains the court's unique structure, including a panel of Supreme Court judges and elected parliament members, which raises concerns about impartiality. Despite over 1000 complaints since 1993, only a few cases have reached judgment. Critics argue the system is too deferential to politicians compared to other countries. While some suggest separating political and judicial responsibilities, the CJR remains in place, with appeals possible to the Supreme Court.

What is the primary function of the CJR in France?

• To oversee civil disputes involving government officials

• To manage international legal cases

• To handle all criminal cases in France

• To try government ministers for crimes during their official duties

What is a notable concern about the composition of the CJR's judgment panel?

• It is composed entirely of foreign judges

• It includes elected members of parliament, raising impartiality concerns

• It includes only Supreme Court judges

• It lacks any legal professionals

How many cases have gone to full judgment in the CJR since its inception?

• Over 1000

• 37

• None

• 6

What do critics say about the French system compared to Britain's?

• It is less formal

• It is more efficient

• It shows too much deference to politicians

• It is more transparent

What option is available if the CJR's decision is not favorable?

• Appeal to the European Court

• Request a retrial in the CJR

• Appeal to the country's Supreme Court

• Seek intervention from the President