Is It Better To Write on Paper or Computer?

The video explores the debate between composing music using paper, piano, or software. It discusses the pros and cons of each method, considering generational perspectives and personal experiences. The speaker shares a hybrid workflow that combines these tools, emphasizing the importance of understanding each tool's strengths and weaknesses. The video concludes with the idea that all technologies are resources to achieve artistic vision.

What is a key reason older generations might prefer composing on paper?

• They think it improves penmanship.

• They find it more environmentally friendly.

• They believe it enhances creativity.

• They grew up without computers.

What is one advantage of composing on paper?

• It automatically corrects errors.

• It ensures perfect penmanship.

• It allows for flexible and unrestricted creativity.

• It provides immediate audible feedback.

Why might composing on a piano be limiting when writing for other instruments?

• Piano compositions are always too simple.

• Piano compositions may not translate well to other instruments.

• Piano compositions are too loud.

• Piano compositions are too fast.

What is a benefit of using a piano in composition?

• It eliminates the need for other instruments.

• It automatically records compositions.

• It provides a wide harmonic range.

• It ensures compositions are playable on all instruments.

What is a major benefit of using software for composing?

• It allows for rapid experimentation and feedback.

• It eliminates the need for musical knowledge.

• It automatically publishes music online.

• It guarantees perfect compositions.

What is a common drawback of composing with software?

• It forces composers to work non-linearly.

• It provides too much creative freedom.

• It can lead to unrealistic musical expectations.

• It is too expensive for most composers.

What is a potential issue when using notation software?

• It automatically changes the tempo.

• It always uses the wrong key signature.

• It only works for piano compositions.

• It can create unrealistic dynamics and instrument ranges.

What is the first step in the hybrid workflow described?

• Recording the composition.

• Sketching ideas on paper.

• Publishing the music online.

• Finalizing the score.

Why is developing an inner ear important for composers?

• It helps in reading music faster.

• It makes them better at playing instruments.

• It allows composers to audiate music in their heads.

• It improves their singing ability.

What is a key conclusion about using technology in composition?

• All technology is a tool to achieve artistic vision.

• Only one type of technology should be used.

• Technology makes compositions less authentic.

• Technology should be avoided in composition.