Senate Race Tightens in Ohio, DeWine Re-Elected

The Ohio Senate race between JD Vance and Tim Ryan is highly competitive, with Vance catching up after early leads by Ryan. Mike Dewine's gubernatorial win may not necessarily benefit Vance due to ticket splitting. Rob Portman endorsed Vance, aligning with his policies. The race hinges on whether Ryan's portrayal of Vance as out of touch resonates with voters.

What argument did Tim Ryan's campaign make against JD Vance?

What factors are being considered regarding the appeal of candidates to moderate and independent voters?