Bekius Quiz 11

If a flower pot with a hole is based in Eretz Yisrael and its branches and fruits are leaning over and hanging outside of Eretz Yisrael. Do you need to take off Maaser?

• Yes according to everyone

• No according to everyone

• Yes according to Abaye, No according to Rava

• Yes according to Rava, No according to Abaye

What statement does the Gemara make about a situation when the flower pot grows roots in the ground in Eretz Yisrael and the fruits are hanging over Chutz La'aretz?

• Everyone would agree that you would be chayav in maaser

• Everyone would agree that you would not be chayav in maaser

• Abaye would say that you are chatav in maaser and Rava would say you are Patur

• Rava would say that you are chatav in maaser and Abaye would say you are Patur

What is the halacha in a case where there is a garden on top and a garden on bottom and a vegetable is sticking out of the side?

• Everyone agrees that the top guy can take it

• Everyone agrees that the bottom guy can take it

• R' Meir says the top guy can take it, R' Yehuda says that the bottom guy can take it

• It depends on how long it has been since it started growing

What is the Gemara trying to show from the case of the top garden and lower garden (why does it mention this case?)?

• That roots are always the thing that makes it chayav

• That airspace is always the thing that makes it chayav

• That we always go after the branches

• That there is an argument even when there are roots in the ground

How does the Gemara end up explaining what the Machlokes by the Gardens is based on.

• Whether the bottom guy is allowed to fill up his garden with dirt.

• Who has a better claim about taking away the ability of the other guy

• Whether we go after the branches or the roots

• If coming out of the side is considered like it's growing from the roots

What is the machlokes between Rebbe and R' Shimon Ben Gamliel ni the case of the tree growing on 2 sides of the border?

• Do you view each fruit as a 50/50 mix of chiyuv maaser or does each fruit depend on which side it's on.

• Is there a rock in the middle of the roots or not

• Are you allowed to plant a tree in the middle of the border

• Are you allowed to purposely arrange it so that the fruits hang over chutz La'aretz

What does the Gemara try to prove from the machlokes Rebbe and R' Shimon Ben Gamliel in he case of the tree on the border? (Why did we mention this case?)

• That the halacha is like R' Shimon Ben Gamliel

• That they argue even in a case where all of the branches are in one side

• That they argue even when there are roots

• That they argue even when there is a rock between the roots

Why did the Gemara originally think it had a proof from the case of the tree on the border and what changed in the maskana?

• Originally we thought there was a rock in the middle of the roots.

  Maskana-There is no rock in the middle of the roots

• Originally-the roots were on one side.

  Maskana-the roots are in the middle

• Originally-the roots were in the middle

  Maskana-the roots are on one side

• Originally they thought there was a machlokes in this case.

  Maskana-Everyone agrees in this case

How does the Gemara end up explaining the Machlokes between Rebbe and R' Shimon Ben Gamliel?

• Whether there are any roots in this case

• Whether we go based on the roots or the airspace

• Whether the nutrients that are separate above land will mix when it gets to the bottom (roots)

• Whether the nutrients that are separate at the bottom (roots) will mix when it gets above land

What are the three types of papers that can be erased?

• matzah, chaifa, diftira

• matza, chaifa, ohr

• matza, ohr, diftira

• ohr, chaifa, diftira