Smash, Boom, Best-Bats vs. Owls

What claim does Brandi make to argue owls are better than bats?

What claim does Katie make to argue bats are better than owls?

What reasons and evidence does Katie give to argue bats are better than owls? Remember--there will be a lot of reasons and evidence!

What is Brandi's rebuttal to Katie's argument that bats are better than owls?

What reasons and evidence does Brandi give to argue owls are better than bats? Remember--there are a lot of reasons and evidence!

What is Katie's rebuttal toward Brandi's argument that owls are better than bats?

Does either debater present a claim that is NOT supported by reasoning or evidence? Explain your answer.

Does either debater present a claim that is NOT supported by reasoning or evidence? Explain your anwer.

Who is the winner of the debate? Explain your decision.

Choose one argument. Is the reasoning given relevant and sufficient? Why or why not?