WorksheetsB&R Ch. 7, pgs. 121-128, "What is an Argument Synthesis?"
Total questions: 48
Worksheet time: 48mins
A(n) ______ is an attempt to persuade a reader or listener that a specific debatable claim is true and worthy of support.
synthesis
argument
analysis
critique
Writers argue in order to...
establish facts
establish facts and to make statements of value
establish facts, to make statements of value, and to recommend policies.
Whether readers would accept your conclusions depends on...
the quality of your supporting evidence
the quality of your supporting evidence and the care and logic with which you have argued your case.
What we are calling an _________ draws on evidence from a variety of sources in an attempt to persuade others of the truth or validity of a debatable claim.
argument synthesis
explanatory synthesis
The writer of an argument synthesis aims to...
inform
persuade
entertain
The following thesis belongs to which kind of synthesis (explanatory or argument)? Smartphones make it possible for us to be always within reach, though many people would prefer not to be always within reach.
explanatory
argument
The following thesis belongs to which kind of synthesis (explanatory or argument)? Smartphones create an illusion of meaningful connection with others and have ruined our ability, perhaps even our desire, to be content while alone.
explanatory
argument
The thesis of an argument synthesis, also called a(n) _______, is a debatable statement about which reasonable people could disagree.
assumption
warrant
claim
Claims should be supported with...
logic in order to persuade others that your view is true or desirable.
evidence in order to persuade others that your view is true or desirable.
logic and evidence in order to persuade others that your view is true or desirable.
(Select all that apply.) One way of understanding argument is to see it as an interplay of three essential elements:
rebuttal
support
claim
qualifier
evidence
Another definition of a claim would be...
a commonly accepted belief or value statement that needs no proof.
support in the form of facts, statistics, and other forms of primary and secondary research.
a proposition or conclusion that you are trying to prove.
You prove this claim by using _______ in the form of fact, statistics, or expert opinion.
warrants
assumptions
support
Linking your supporting evidence to your claim is your _______ about the subject. This is an underlying belief or principle about some aspect of the world and how it operates.
warrant
assumption
support
As you may recall, another term for the assumption linking a claim to its support is called a(n)_______.
warrant
assumption
support
By their nature, assumptions (which are often unstated) tend to be more _______ than either claims or supporting evidence.
specific
general
Is the following statement a claim, support, or assumption? High school students should watch no more than two hours of TV per day.
assumption
support
claim
Is the following statement a claim, support, or assumption? An important new study and the testimony of educational specialists reveal that students who watch more than two hours of TV a night have, on average, lower grades than those who watch less TV.
assumption
support
claim
Is the following statement a claim, support, or assumption? Excessive TV viewing adversely affects academic performance.
assumption
support
claim
Is the following statement a claim, support, or assumption? The ubiquity of smartphones threatens to undermine human intimacy, connection, and ultimately community.
assumption
support
claim
Is the following set of statements claims, support, or assumptions?
*People are spending increasing amounts of time on smartphones: In 2015, owners of smartphones spent, on average, 7.7 hours per day on their devices.
*College health officials report that excessive smartphone use threatens many college students’ academic and psychological well-being.
*To encourage direct human-to-human interaction, some restaurants have begun offering discounts to patrons who turn off their smartphones during the meal.
*New kinds of relationships fostered on smartphones can pose challenges to preexisting relationships.
assumptions
support
claims
Is the following set of statements claims, support, or assumptions?
*The communication skills used and the connections formed during smartphone interactions fundamentally differ from those used and formed during face-to-face contact.
*“Real” connection and a sense of community are sustained by face-to-face contact, not by digital interactions.
assumptions
support
claims
Speakers and writers have never relied on ___(1)____ alone in ___(2)____ and ___(3)____ their claims.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) problematic; 2) sole; 3) basis
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) logic; 2) evidence; 3) pathos
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
More than 2000 years ago, the Athenian philosopher and ____(1)_____ Aristotle explained how speakers attempting to persuade others to adopt their point of view could achieve their ___(2)____ by relying on one or more ___(3)____.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) problematic; 2) sole; 3) basis
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) logic; 2) evidence; 3) pathos
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
Aristotle called these appeals...
ethos, chronos, and pathos
logos, chronos, and kairos
logos, ethos, and pathos
pathos, chronos, and kairos
In academic writing, the appeal to logic, ________, is by far the most commonly used appeal.
pathos
logos
ethos
Logos is also defined as...
the ethical appeal, the appeal to character.
the emotional appeal, the appeal to the "heart."
the rational appeal, the appeal to reason.
Logical arguments are commonly of two types (often combined):
deductive and invective.
inductive and invective.
deductive and inductive.
inductive and polemic.
The ________ argument begins with a generalization, then cites a specific case related to that generalization from which follows a conclusion.
inductive
deductive
An example of a deductive argument may be seen in...
a debate on gun control in which former Senator Robert C. Byrd cited specific examples of rampant crime involving guns.
President John F. Kennedy's address to the nation in June 1963 on the need for sweeping civil rights legislation.
Underlying Kennedy's argument is this reasoning: All Americans should enjoy certain rights. Is this an assumption or a claim?
claim
assumption
Underlying Kennedy's argument is this reasoning: Some Americans do not enjoy these rights. Is this a claim or support?
support
claim
Underlying Kennedy's argument is this reasoning: We must take action to ensure that all Americans enjoy these rights. Is this a claim or support?
support
claim
An argument that uses ______ reasoning begins not with a generalization but with several pieces of specific evidence. The speaker then draws a conclusion from this evidence.
inductive
deductive
For example, in a debate on gun control, former Senator Robert C. Byrd cited specific examples of rampant crime involving guns:
"All Americans should enjoy certain rights."
"We must take action to ensure that all Americans enjoy these rights."
"Some Americans do not enjoy these rights."
"I read of young men being viciously murdered for a pair of sneakers, a leather jacket, or $20."
Of course, the mere ___(1)_____ of ____(2)_____ does not in itself make the speaker's case.
1) piling up; 2) evidence
1) evidence; 2) piling up
As Donna Cross explains in “Politics: The Art of Bamboozling,” politicians are very adept at __________—lining up evidence in favor of a conclusion without bothering to mention (or barely mentioning) contrary evidence.
false analogizing
hasty generalizations
diversions (also called red herrings)
card-stacking
The ethical appeal, or _______, is based not on the ethics relating to the subject under discussion but rather on the ethical status of the person making the argument.
pathos
logos
ethos
(Select all that apply.) A person making an argument must have a certain degree of credibility:
That person must have sound sense.
That person must be qualified to argue based either on expert experience with the subject matter or on carefully conducted research.
That person must make their argument persuasively.
That person must be of good character.
Appeals to ethos are usually most explicit in...
scientific studies.
political contests.
legal cases.
secondary research analyses.
(Select all that apply.) As a "consumer" of political arguments—that is, as a voter—ask:
"Can I relate to the speaker?"
“Does this appeal to personal qualifications matter?”
"Do I agree with what the speaker is saying?"
“Am I persuaded that personal traits will translate to policies that I support?“
“Do I agree that this candidate is of upstanding character?”
Finally, speakers and writers appeal to their audiences by using ______, an appeal to the emotions.
pathos
logos
ethos
Writers in academic settings rely heavily on the force of ___(1)____ and ____(2)____, and rarely make appeals to ___(3)____. Beyond academic settings, however, emotional appeals are common.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) problematic; 2) sole; 3) basis
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) logic; 2) evidence; 3) pathos
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
Nothing is inherently wrong with using an emotional appeal. The emotional appeal becomes ___(1)____ only when it is the __(2)___ or primary ___(3)_____ of the argument.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) problematic; 2) sole; 3) basis
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) logic; 2) evidence; 3) pathos
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
President ____________ was a master of emotional appeal. He closed his first inaugural address with a reference to the view from the Capitol to the Arlington National Cemetery, where lie thousands of markers of "heroes."
Barack Obama
Richard Nixon
Jimmy Carter
Ronald Reagan
Our discussion of ethos and pathos indicates a potentially troubling but undeniable reality:
Arguments are won on the basis of logic and evidence alone.
Arguments are not won on the basis of logic and evidence alone.
For emotionally loaded topics like capital punishment, abortion, or police brutality, it is extremely ____(1)____, if not ____(2)___, to get people to change their minds because they are so personally invested in their ____(3)_____.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) problematic; 2) sole; 3) basis
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) logic; 2) evidence; 3) pathos
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
As Susan Jacoby, author of The Age of American Unreason, notes: “Whether watching television news, consulting political blogs, or (more rarely) reading books, Americans today have become a people in search of ____(1)____ for ___(2)____ that they already ___(3)___.”
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) validation; 2) opinions; 3) hold
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) tenacity; 2) off limits; 3) reasoned
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
The ___(1)____ with which people hold onto longtime beliefs does not mean, however, that they cannot change their minds or that subjects like abortion, capital punishment, and gun control should be ___(2)___ to ___(3)____ debate.
1) rhetorician; 2) purpose; 3) appeals
1) validation; 2) opinions; 3) hold
1) logic; 2) advancing; 3) supporting
1) tenacity; 2) off limits; 3) reasoned
1) difficult; 2) impossible; 3) beliefs
