WorksheetsWeekly Quiz on Fallacies and the Toulmin Model
Total questions: 30
Worksheet time: 30mins
America is the best place to live, because it's better than any other country.
ad hominem
red herring
circular logic
straw man
"Russia has a terrible human rights record." "Well, the United States has done plenty of bad things." -the President when confronted about Russia's human rights abuses.
slippery slope
red herring
moral equivalence
non sequitur
Trans fats are as bad as biological weapons.
either/or (black/white) (binary)
non sequitur
ad hominem
moral equivalence
We should stop using hairspray because it is snowing in New York.
hasty generalization
non sequitur
ad hominem
moral equivalence
Al Gore feels that all companies are irresponsible and should be punished for allowing emissions which causes global warming.
straw man
red herring
slippery slope
either/or (black/white) (binary)
It is warmer this year in Las Vegas as compared to last year; therefore, global warming is rapidly accelerating.
slippery slope
red herring
circular reasoning
hasty generalization
If we use just one more can of hairspray this month, earth as we know it will no longer exist.
hasty generalization
slippery slope
red herring
straw man
We cannot listen to John’s opinion on global warming because he is a tree hugger.
ad hominem
circular reasoning
straw man
red herring
The news is fake because so much of the news is fake.
ad hominem
moral equivalence
non sequitur
circular reasoning
The conclusions that one thing caused another simply because one happened before the other.
false dichotomy
false causality
circular reasoning
guilt by association
Drawing a conclusion based on a small sample size; a broad claim based on limited evidence.
non sequitur
false causation
red herring
hasty generalization
An argument that misleads, distracts, or diverts attention from a relevant or important issue.
straw man argument
false causation
red herring
hasty generalization
"The Cardinals are the best football team because they're better than all the other teams."
hasty generalization
circular reasoning
straw man argument
ad hominem
"Every time I go to sleep the sun goes down. Therefore, my sleeping causes the sun to set."
false dichotomy
false causation
circular reasoning
guilt by association
Either you love bacon, or you're wrong.
Hasty Generalization
Post Hoc
Bandwagon Appeals
False Dilemma (aka either - or)
What is a logical fallacy?
An argument with a premise and a conclusion
An argument that contains a non-statement
An argument that contains a mistake in reasoning
a logical, sound argument
Match the following definition with its term: The explanations that connect the parts of an argument. Answers the question, "Why does your evidence support the claim?"
Warrant
Claim
Ground
Conditions of Rebuttal
Modal Qualifier
Match the following definition with its term: Also called evidence, data, the “facts,” support, or reasoning of the
argument. These answer the question, “What’s your proof?”
Warrant
Claim
Ground
Conditions of Rebuttal
Modal Qualifier
Match the following definition with its term: The conclusions or the positions. A basic argument consists of a ________ and stated reason.
Warrant
Claim
Ground
Conditions of Rebuttal
Modal Qualifier
Match the following definition with its term: Arguments against or limiting the scope of the claim. These answer the question, “In what situations is your claim not true?”
Warrant
Claim
Ground
Conditions of Rebuttal
Modal Qualifier
BACKING is the additional ________s in support of the warrant. These depend heavily on the context of the ________. Answers the question, "What makes your assumption valid?"
(a)
When crafting an argument, if your audience is likely to question your assumptions, you should...
provide more grounds for your claim
state your warrant explicitly
make your modal qualifier more limiting
prepare a counter argument for an anticipated rebuttal
Use __________ as additional support if readers are likely to doubt the reasoning in your warrant.
backing
evidence
data
facts
2. Which of the following is NOT an element of the Toulmin model?
grounds
warrant
support
rebuttal
backing
3. In a Toulmin model, the idea you are arguing for or against is called the:
claim
thesis
qualifier
warrant
grounds
In a Toulmin model, you use a(n) ________ to avoid making absolute statements, so you will not be disproven based on unusual cases or situations.
warrant
rebuttal
qualifier
support
example
5. Which one of these terms does not go with the others?
grounds
evidence
data
reasons
TRICK--they all go together
Imagine you are writing a paper which advocates lowering the voting age to sixteen. Identify the Toulmin element this statement represents.
"Increased political activity is good for democracy."
claim
warrant
evidence
grounds
backing
Imagine you are writing a paper which advocates lowering the voting age to sixteen. Identify the Toulmin element this statement represents.
"While some may argue that sixteen-year-olds are too immature to vote, in all states that is the legal age to drive."
evidence
claim
warrant
qualifier
rebuttal
